comparison of five calligraphy brush pens

In my toolbox: A review of five brush calligraphy pens

Having the right tools can make all the difference in your brush calligraphy journey. It’s important to find the brush pen or set of pens that you feel comfortable with, understand how to use, and enjoy.

You don’t need a hundred pens, or even ten. You just need one or two, maybe three, that are your “go-to” pens.

Preferably, your brush pens should be different in some way, such as tip size,  flex, or color. This gives you options as you complete various projects. For example, you may use a smaller tip pen to write on a gift tag, but a larger, stiffer pen for a poster.

Take a look inside my toolbox to see the five brush pens I am currently using. I’ll describe each one, including pros and cons. Then you can watch my demonstration video where you will see each pen in action.

A review of five brush calligraphy pens

comparison of five calligraphy brush pens

*This post contains affiliate links. I would greatly appreciate if you would use the links in this post to purchase your supplies. At no extra cost to you, I will receive a small commission that will help me continue to provide free brush calligraphy tutorials and videos!

  1. Tombow Dual Brush Pens: With a flexible brush tip on one end and a fine point on the other, this pen is perfect for calligraphy and illustration. I like to use the brush tip for brush calligraphy and the fine point for touching up, or for simple print. The pen itself is fairly large, so it takes some getting used to.
    In action: Tombow dual brush pen

    In action: Tombow dual brush pen

    The best part about the dual brushes… The color options are endless! The fun thing  can be blended using a blending palette or by putting the ink of one pen onto the tip of another. And they are “self-cleaning,” meaning after you blend them, they will return to their original color as you continue to use them. There is a full set of 96 colors that is on my own wish list.

  2. Tombow Fudenosuke Brush Pens: These pens are perfect for the beginning brush calligrapher. They come in either a hard tip or soft tip, or both! The tip of these pens is much smaller than the dual brush, which make them ideal for writing in smaller sized calligraphy/lettering, or for writing longer pieces. 
    In action: Tombow Fudenosuke (soft tip)

    In action: Tombow Fudenosuke (soft tip)

    The hard and soft tips differ in the stiffness of the pen tip. The hard tip is more firm and seems to create thinner hairlines (upstrokes) than soft tip. While the flexibility of the soft tip can make it difficult to control the pen, I really like that the pen tip maintains a degree of firmness, that makes it a great beginner brush pen. If I had to share a downfall, it would be the lack of color options that they come in. Aside from the twin tip (one side is gray), these pens only come in black.

  3. Pentel Sign Pens (with brush tip): The Pentel sign pen is a wonderful brush pen for beginners. It is very similar to the Tombow Fudenosuke described previously. It has a small pen tip, is fairly flexible, and is very easy to control. It comes in 12 fun colors you can choose from, or you can be a collector (like me) and get the entire set of 12.


    In action: Pentel sign pen (with brush tip)

    In action: Pentel sign pen (with brush tip)

    NOTE: Be sure to get the Pentel sign pen with a brush tip (also called the “fude touch”), do not get the Pentel fine point (not a brush pen).

  4. Sakura Koi Watercolor Brush Pens: The Koi coloring brush pens are similar to the Tombow dual brush pen in pen tip size, but are much smaller in terms of the pen itself (the outer shell). The smaller size makes the Koi an easier pen to handle, and less overwhelming than the larger size of the dual brush.
    In action: Koi coloring brush

    In action: Koi coloring brush

    In addition to the smaller pen size, what I love about the Koi brushes is the firmness of the tip. It achieves smooth strokes and is full of ink and color. The Koi brushes come in either a 12 pack or a 24 pack of colors, which makes for lots of blending and coloring fun!

  5. Sakura Pigma Professional Brush Pen: The Pigma brush pens are pretty new to me and I am already loving them! They come in a fine, medium, and bold tip, which allows for a good amount of options when choosing what size writing you want to create. The pens only come in black ink (darn!).
    In action: Sakura pigma professional brush

    In action: Sakura pigma professional brush

    The interesting thing about the Pigma brushes is that they have a raw look to their strokes. This raw look is sometimes categorized as “frayed” or “furry,” at least in comparison to the pens described above. However, I am loving this look as it better resembles an actual paint brush with bristles, while still being a marker that you do not have to refill or dip into ink.

Choosing a Brush Pen

When choosing a brush pen, it is important to recognizes the differences in pens and your own personal preferences and needs. My best advice is to try as many different pens as you can. And try them more than once! You never know when you will begin to love a pen, or if there is just something better out there than what you currently use.

Some tips for choosing a brush pen:

  1. Learn how to hold the pen. You need to know how to properly hold the pen in order to test it completely and thoroughly.
  2. Practice some basic strokes with each pen to learn how it writes. Don’t just start writing. Rather, do a few basic strokes to test the waters, and then gradually increase to writing letters and words.
  3. Ask around. Aside from my comparison posts and videos, ask other brush calligraphers and handlettering artists to get their opinions and experiences with pens.

Video: Review of five brush calligraphy pens

Other Resources

Check out the following resources for more brush pen reviews and comparisons:

A Simple Guide to Brush Pens by Melissa Esplin

How to Choose a Brush Pen by JetPens

~ ~ ~

It’s your turn! Tell me in a comment below:

What’s in your toolbox?

What is your favorite pen from the ones I have described in this post? Which is your least favorite

What brush pen would you like to see me try next?


~ ~ ~


Sharisse signature - pieces calligraphy





P.S. If you liked this post, please share it with a friend!

P. P. S. If you haven’t already done so, subscribe to my blog below so you get my posts directly in your inbox!

Follow me on Instagram: @piecescalligraphy

Watch more videos on YouTube: piecescalligraphy

~ ~ ~

Supplies used in this post and video:

You can view my full list of supplies on my supplies page.

23 thoughts on “In my toolbox: A review of five brush calligraphy pens

  1. Marc says:

    Lovely post, I’ve always been curious about the Sakura Koi ones, I might actually give them a try when I next do my impulse online shopping for pens. Thanks for those recommendations!

    Curious on your view on the Zig Fudebiyori, Akashiya Sai and the Zig Cocoiro? I’ve seen those as a popular brush lettering/calligraphy tools people use and just wondering if you’ve used it and what you thought of them🙂


  2. Beverly says:

    Hi Sharisse, I loved your pen comparison video. Thank you! At the moment I’m favoring the Pentel brush pen but at the same time very curious about the Kuretake Pocket Brush Pens. Do you think you could do a demo with these and tell us if beginner’s might like these as well? Thanks again for all of the well done online brush calligraphy instruction!


  3. Andrea Goo says:

    Santa brought me a set of the Pentel Sign brush pens for Christmas, and I’m just loving them. I find them easier to work with than the Tombow brush pens. Their tips are a bit smaller than the Tombow pens and the brush tip is a bit less flexible, making it easier for me to achieve fine strokes.


    • piecescalligraphy says:

      WOO HOO!!! So glad you like them. I honestly love both Pentels and Tombow dual brushes in their own way… sort of like a mom with her children! They are all different, but equally loved.😉 It’s so hard for me to play favorites! Anyway, enjoy and happy writing!


  4. Erin says:

    This is very helpful Sharisse – thank you! It’s so fun to experiment with new pens. Question – how did you get that lovely gradient effect in your signature? Was that from blending Tombows or a watercolor pen?


    • piecescalligraphy says:

      Hi Erin! I used a Koi coloring brush in my signature. The gradient is a combination of the juicy ink in the Koi brush pen and probably the filters I used in a photo app, which enhanced the gradient. No blending at all, which makes the Koi pens really fun and easy to use.🙂


  5. Kristin says:

    Hi Sharisse! I am loving your blog! I was curious if you have tried the Copic brush pens? If so, how do they compare to the five you have posted about? Thanks so much! I look forward to learning more from you.🙂


    • piecescalligraphy says:

      Hey Kristin! Thank you for visiting! And NO! I have not (yet) tried the Copic brush pens. Molly of Poppy and Mint Design raves about them… I will certainly add that to my “must-try” list! Thanks again and happy writing!


  6. Mona says:

    wow, I’m in love with that tombow pen ♥ still love my pentel brush on marker paper the most but I’ll keep that pen in mind😀 can imagine it to be wonderful in addition


  7. Pingback: pieces calligraphy
  8. Jessica Shubert says:

    Love love love this blog post! I’m more use to nib and ink so I’m trying to expand into the brush lettering word–which I have to admit, I think you are at the top of! Thanks for the advice on pens. I have a jillion Tomboy Dual Brush Pens, but haven’t ventured past that point! Can’t wait to try out the others.


  9. Renata Amelia Kussoy says:

    Hi Sharisse! you know what, i really wanted to learn brush calligraphy but i didn’t know what to do, i didn’t know how to learn it, and i thought that lefty (i’m lefty) can’t do it. until i accidentally saw you on pinterest and i saw your tutorials, tips, etc one by one and it is so helpful!! I have learned so much, thank you!
    i’m still beginner, i dont know much about brush pens. how long the brush pen will last? i use Sakura Koi Watercolor Brush Pens when practicing, but after 2 days, the ink is finished, is that okay? thankyou!


    • piecescalligraphy says:

      Hi Renata! So glad you found me. Hmm, I have had my Koi coloring brushes for a couple of months now and they’re still full of ink and write really well. Maybe the cap was not tight enough? Are all of your pens dried up, or just certain ones?


Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s